People v. Alvin & Bill

You are a judge and must reach a decision in the following case: (Because there are only 2 answers, guilty or not guilty, its ok to duplicate someone elses decision. Just make sure you fully explain your reasoning.) Alvin, Bill and Charley are partners and prospectors in a diamond mine in Strayer State. They fear tresspassers might steal diamonds from the mine when they are away, so they keep the location of their mine a closely …

…his two partners to hold the value of the mine for himself. This decision was a selfless act for survival were exceptional circumstances did in fact take place. Alvin and Bill you are free to go. Our hearts go out to you and the families of Charley. It is the advice of this court that you seek comfort in your friend extraordinary bravery and sacrifice. This Court is now adjourned, Call in the next case.